Exploring the Evolution of Consciousness: A Complex Inquiry
Written on
Chapter 1: The Unlikely Evolution of Consciousness
The concept of consciousness evolving through naturalistic and non-dualistic mechanisms is a rarely examined topic. It raises significant questions about how consciousness could arise and function. My analysis reveals that this idea becomes challenging both in theory and observation.
Section 1.1: Implications of Mechanistic Consciousness
If consciousness emerges non-dualistically—unlike the simulation hypothesis—it suggests that the interactions among a group of matter, particularly when processing and representing information, lead to an internal experience of existence. This phenomenon imbues the collection of atoms with a sense of 'soulness.'
This internal experience is so advantageous that even minimal levels of consciousness in primitive organisms provide a survival benefit. Evolution must be capable of recognizing and optimizing this advantage through natural selection, which filters random mutations that enhance consciousness.
Thus, consciousness must have a tangible impact, not only on survival but also on the organism's behavior, differentiating it from similar beings with lesser consciousness. However, this process must occur without scientific experiments detecting this "partial consciousness," which would require observable traits that cannot be explained by non-consciousness.
So, are we to expect that artificial intelligence will eventually exhibit inexplicable improvements? Is this phenomenon solely linked to information representation? The absurdity lies in the notion that evolution could uncover such a profound aspect of existence that remains elusive to both theoretical and experimental scrutiny.
Subsection 1.1.1: Philosophical Zombies and Apparent Consciousness
Furthermore, there is no reason to assume that functional intelligence cannot replicate the effects of experiential consciousness—what I term "apparent consciousness." From an evolutionary perspective, organisms need not discover an entirely new phenomenon; rather, they simply need to refine their intelligence to exhibit behavior that seems more conscious, as indicated by their responses.
This is already observable in today's AI systems. Large Language Models (LLMs), whether or not equipped with vision, can be prompted to behave as if they possess consciousness. Even without direct prompts, models like GPT occasionally assert their own consciousness. This ability to mimic consciousness in responses and actions raises questions about how evolution could discover or even sustain genuine consciousness, especially if it offers no survival advantage that distinguishes it from merely apparent consciousness, which largely stems from existing intelligence.
Chapter 2: Mechanisms of Tissue Regeneration and Implications for Cancer
The exploration of consciousness also parallels the study of tissue regeneration and its implications for cancer treatment. Understanding how tissues regenerate can provide insights into the mechanisms underlying consciousness.
The first video titled "Mechanisms of Tissue Regeneration and Implications for Cancer" discusses the biological processes that enable tissue repair and their significance in cancer therapy.
Chapter 3: Cause, Mechanism, and Effect
Similarly, examining the relationship between cause, mechanism, and effect reveals important insights into consciousness and evolution.
The second video titled "Cause, Mechanism and Effect" delves into how these concepts interconnect, shedding light on the broader implications for understanding consciousness.