The Challenges of Quantum Computing: Supply Chain Struggles
Written on
Chapter 1: The Rise of Quantum Computing
Quantum machines are on the brink of revolutionizing computing, yet the pursuit of essential components poses significant challenges for researchers. As quantum technology transitions from experimental to mainstream, driven by major players like IBM, Google, and Alibaba, the demand for specialized parts has surged, outpacing availability.
Section 1.1: The Component Crisis
Blake Johnson, vice president of quantum engineering at Rigetti Computing, dedicates his efforts to sourcing crucial components, such as superconducting cables and ultra-cooled refrigerators. The shortage of these exotic materials is slowing the momentum of quantum computing development. It may take months, or even over a year, to acquire specialized dilution refrigerators that reach temperatures colder than outer space, necessary for creating qubits—the fundamental units of quantum information.
Section 1.2: Exotic Technology Limitations
The unique nature of quantum computers requires entirely different infrastructure than classical systems. As Chris Monroe, CEO of IonQ, explains, the hardware is inherently exotic due to the underlying principles of quantum mechanics. Unlike classical bits, which hold a value of either 0 or 1, qubits can exist in a superposition of both states simultaneously, only determining their value upon measurement. This property, along with entanglement, could enable quantum computers to surpass current supercomputers, but the engineering hurdles remain substantial.
Chapter 2: The Supply Chain Dilemma
The challenges associated with acquiring dilution refrigerators are compounded by their high cost, ranging from $500,000 to $1 million, and the limited manufacturers producing high-quality units, such as BlueFors and Oxford Instruments. Additionally, the supercooling process requires helium-3, a rare isotope with controlled availability, further complicating the supply chain.
The video titled "How Quantum Computers Could Solve The World's Biggest Problems - Moonshot S02E08" explores the potential of quantum computing to tackle significant challenges. Despite its promise, the video highlights the ongoing difficulties in sourcing the necessary components for quantum machines.
Section 2.1: The Cabling Conundrum
Another critical aspect of quantum computing is the superconducting cables that convey microwave signals to control qubits. Johnson notes that a single manufacturer, Coax Co. from Japan, predominantly supplies these specialized cables, which are essential for maintaining the delicate quantum states within the refrigerators.
Section 2.2: Alternative Approaches
While there are alternative methods to construct quantum computers that do not rely on cryogenic technology, they come with their own set of challenges. For instance, IonQ employs electromagnetic fields to trap atoms on silicon chips within ultra-high-vacuum chambers, a method requiring specialized gold deposits that traditional manufacturing facilities are not equipped to handle.
As the field evolves, efforts are being made to engage more companies in quantum technology, with initiatives like the new US national plan for quantum information science aiming to stimulate supplier interest. Startups such as Delft Circuits in the Netherlands are also stepping in to develop innovative solutions for qubit management and control.
Martin Giles serves as the San Francisco bureau chief for MIT Technology Review, focusing on the future of computing and the transformative companies in Silicon Valley. Follow him on Twitter @MartinGiles.