Exploring the Illusion of Free Will and Its Impact on Society
Written on
Chapter 1: The Concept of Free Will
The ongoing discourse surrounding the idea of "free will" has garnered significant attention. Various neuroscientists, philosophers, and even some unconventional thinkers argue that free will may not exist at all. According to this perspective, our actions are not merely influenced by our life experiences but are also shaped by unconscious processes within our central nervous system that make choices far quicker than our conscious minds can comprehend.
This notion raises the question: how do we account for major societal shifts? Who drives social revolutions? Is there a collective awakening, reminiscent of ancient Greece, where a society suddenly declares, “Slavery is unjust; let’s strive for independence”?
Such decisions regarding social progress are seldom instantaneous. Much like biological evolution, societal advancement does not follow a linear path but is influenced by environmental factors that gradually alter our behaviors. Perhaps we adapt subtly to new information, leading to enhanced social cohesion and improved reproductive outcomes.
Section 1.1: Social Evolution and Its Challenges
If the concept of social free will is indeed an illusion, I am apprehensive about the present moment. It appears that our capacity for social free will may hinge on gradual enlightenment that fosters improved societal decisions. If this is the case, we could inflict considerable harm on individuals and the planet before meaningful reform occurs.
For instance, Brazil is on the brink of an election. An authoritarian leader, who has shown indifference towards the Amazon and its inhabitants, as well as employing homophobia, misogyny, and racism to manipulate millions, could potentially be re-elected. Should Bolsonaro lose, he has already mobilized his military and supporters to contest the election results, reminiscent of the events of January 6, albeit in a more militarized context.
As tensions rise in Europe and a potential global culture war looms—pitting the affluent against the impoverished—our social free will must either emerge as a savior or lead us to our demise.
Section 1.2: The Fine Line Between Free Will and Determinism
On a daily basis, it seems that a blend of both outcomes occurs. Yet, the stakes are high: if we lose vital environmental resources or if geopolitical tensions escalate into conflict, our future becomes uncertain.
It begs the question: can we truly categorize our existence as one of free will or complete lack thereof?
If we are to consider this so-called "illusion," it compels us to critically assess our free will—both as individuals and as a society. If there exists any force within the universe that grants us agency, we must exhaust every effort to uncover it. Conversely, if we accept that we have no inherent free will, we risk succumbing to despair.
Ultimately, we are intrinsically linked to our environment. We are products of Creation, and in turn, we contribute to that Creation. It seems implausible to think otherwise.
Chapter 2: The Role of Social Awareness in Free Will
This first video, Determined: Life without Free Will with Robert Sapolsky, explores the implications of a life devoid of free will, discussing how our understanding of choice and agency is deeply intertwined with societal structures.
The second video, Science Suggests Free Will Doesn't Exist, delves into scientific perspectives that challenge the existence of free will, prompting viewers to reconsider their beliefs about autonomy and decision-making in the context of societal evolution.