# The Legacy of Emmy Noether: A Pioneering Force in Mathematics and Physics

Written on

One of the most distinguished mathematicians of the 20th century, Emmy Noether encountered significant obstacles due to her gender during an era when academia was largely closed to women. Despite these challenges and her relatively short life, she made revolutionary contributions to mathematics and had a lasting effect on the development of physics.

Born in 1882 in Erlangen, Germany, Amalie Emmy Noether was part of a family rich in mathematical talent. Her father, Max Noether, was a respected professor at the University of Erlangen and a notable figure in algebraic geometry, while her uncle Fritz also pursued mathematics with a focus on applied disciplines.

Throughout the 19th century, European and American universities were generally inaccessible to women. In Germany, educational opportunities for girls were limited to age 14, effectively curtailing any hopes of higher education. However, as the century drew to a close, this rigid framework began to loosen, opening doors to new academic opportunities for women.

In the late 1800s, the notion of women attending universities faced skepticism and opposition. In 1898, the academic senate at the University of Erlangen famously stated that allowing women to enroll could disrupt the established academic atmosphere.

In a significant shift, Emmy Noether was allowed to attend university lectures in 1900, although she was not officially enrolled as a student. This marked a critical advancement for women in academia. Seeking further knowledge, she moved to Göttingen in 1903, immersing herself in the dynamic intellectual environment that was then a global center for mathematics. During her time there, she learned from esteemed figures such as Karl Schwarzschild, Felix Klein, Hermann Minkowski, and David Hilbert. The University of Erlangen revised its policies in 1904, enabling Emmy to return and officially begin her doctoral studies. By 1907, she had earned her doctorate, a testament to her determination and love for mathematics.

After receiving her doctorate, Noether chose to stay at the University of Erlangen, where she engaged in research, mentored doctoral students, and occasionally substituted for her father in lectures. Unfortunately, her contributions during this period went uncompensated.

In 1915, at the invitation of David Hilbert, she moved to Göttingen. However, she encountered similar challenges there, as women were still barred from teaching positions. Initially, Noether had to present her courses as Hilbert's without formal acknowledgment of her role. It wasn't until 1919 that she began teaching under her own name, marking a significant achievement in her career. However, it wasn’t until 1923 that she started receiving payment for her invaluable contributions.

The rise of the Nazi regime in Germany in 1933 led to the expulsion of Jewish academics, including Emmy Noether. Forced to leave her position and her homeland, she was presented with opportunities at Bryn Mawr College in the U.S. and Somerville College in England. She chose the former, embarking on a new chapter in America, where she also began lecturing at the prestigious Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton University. Tragically, her life was cut short at the age of 53 in 1935 due to surgical complications, but her legacy in mathematics and physics endures.

Noether’s doctoral dissertation, supervised by Paul Gordan, was titled "Invariant Theory of Ternary Biquadratics." In this influential work, she identified 331 invariant forms of ternary biquadratics, demonstrating her exceptional talent in concrete calculus. Following her PhD, Noether shifted her focus to abstract algebra, and this transition solidified her reputation as one of the leading mathematicians of her time. Hermann Weyl praised her for introducing a revolutionary approach to algebra. Today, many mathematical concepts bear her name, highlighting her unparalleled contributions.

The impact of 20th-century mathematics, particularly abstract algebra, on modern physics is profound. Emmy Noether significantly influenced physics through her crucial mathematical theorems and groundbreaking work. Her landmark 1918 paper introduced theorems that revealed the deep mathematical connection between conservation laws and symmetries in physics, shaping the trajectory of theoretical physics and underscoring her integral role in the intertwined advancements of mathematics and physics.

Noether’s examination of symmetry and conservation laws marked a unique focus within her scientific pursuits. This foray into physics was prompted by an invitation from Hilbert, marking a significant shift in her research direction.

In 1905, Albert Einstein introduced his special theory of relativity, laying the groundwork for a more comprehensive theoretical framework that would encompass gravitation. Among those involved was David Hilbert, who, along with others, sought to expand on this general theory. When Emmy Noether joined Göttingen in 1915, Einstein began delivering seminars on his progress toward general relativity. Although his formulation was incomplete, he effectively garnered the attention of prominent mathematicians, including Hilbert and Klein. By November of that year, both Einstein and Hilbert had independently derived the field equations for gravitation, now recognized as the general theory of relativity.

Despite the theory’s completion, certain aspects, particularly the principle of energy conservation, remained elusive. Efforts to formulate an equation representing this principle within general relativity led to results that felt circular and unprecedented. Faced with this dilemma, Hilbert and Klein sought Noether’s expertise to provide clarity.

In late 1915, Noether informed Ernst Fischer that Hilbert had planned a seminar to discuss his insights into Einstein's theories, highlighting the importance of their preparation. This correspondence indicates Hilbert's early involvement in physical theories at that time.

Noether’s groundbreaking work in general relativity and energy conservation centered on her realization that in theories like general relativity, physical laws remain invariant under arbitrary differential coordinate transformations. This insight is now recognized as Noether's second theorem. During her exploration leading to this theorem, she uncovered a significant link between physical symmetries and conservation laws, presenting another theorem that would significantly impact theoretical physics for generations. These findings provided a mathematical foundation that deepened the understanding of physical laws, unifying various phenomena under a shared framework of symmetries and conservation.

## Symmetry and Conservation Laws

Conservation principles, including those governing energy and momentum, are crucial in theoretical physics. These principles are often employed to predict a system's evolution over time. Initially, equations representing these total conservation principles are established. These equations subsequently serve as the basis for forecasting changes within the system.

Noether’s theorem establishes a profound connection between conservation laws—such as those for energy, momentum, and electric charge—and the symmetries present in a system. This principle asserts that each symmetry observed corresponds to a specific conservation law and vice versa. In simpler terms, to identify the quantities in a system that remain constant over time, one must examine the symmetries exhibited by that system. This remarkable insight bridges abstract symmetries and tangible conservation laws, illuminating the fundamental principles governing physical systems.

Noether's theorem shifts the focus from "discontinuous" symmetries observable in everyday life to the concept of "continuous" symmetries. For example, consider an equilateral triangle, which demonstrates discontinuous symmetry. Rotating it by 120, 240, or 360 degrees around an axis perpendicular to its plane keeps its appearance unchanged. However, if the rotation angle deviates from these specific values, the triangle's appearance changes. This scenario illustrates how the symmetry parameter, the angle of rotation, is constrained to discrete values.

In contrast, Noether's theorem does not address such discontinuous symmetries; it focuses on continuous symmetries, where parameters can take any value within a specified range. This distinction means that the transformations under Noether's consideration do not need to follow fixed increments or conditions but can vary fluidly and infinitely within the system’s constraints.

To further clarify the relationship between symmetries and conservation laws as outlined by Noether’s theorem, we will explore several practical examples.

Imagine a system with numerous particles. The initial step in predicting the movements of these particles over time involves establishing a coordinate system and identifying each particle's coordinates at a specific moment. The placement of this coordinate system is entirely arbitrary. Shifting the coordinate system by a given amount in a particular direction (or visualizing the coordinate system as fixed while the particles move in the opposite direction) does not alter the physical predictions for the system.

For instance, if a prediction in the original coordinate system states that a particle will gradually accelerate, this remains true in the new setup. Similarly, if two particles are expected to collide after a certain time in the original coordinate system, the adjusted system will predict the same timing for the collision. This phenomenon, where outcomes remain unchanged despite shifts in the coordinate system, demonstrates translational symmetry within the system. Moreover, the symmetry parameter is variable. According to Noether’s theorem, this kind of continuous symmetry correlates with a specific conservation law. Upon analysis, it becomes evident that the conserved quantity over time is the total linear momentum of the system, illustrating a direct relationship between the conservation of linear momentum and translational symmetry.

Now, consider a scenario where the coordinate system undergoes rotation around an axis by any degree, rather than merely translating it. Similar to the previous example, this rotation alters the coordinates but does not affect the actual physical events within the system. Noether’s theorem indicates that such rotational symmetry is directly linked to a conservation law. A closer examination reveals that the conserved quantity over time is the total angular momentum of the system, establishing a clear correlation between the preservation of angular momentum and rotational symmetry.

Just as translational symmetry in spatial dimensions accounts for the conservation of linear momentum, translational symmetry across the temporal dimension underpins energy conservation. Similarly, the conservation of electric charge arises from a specific form of gauge symmetry in quantum electrodynamics, known as U(1) symmetry. This interconnectedness emphasizes the essential role of symmetry in elucidating the enduring nature of fundamental physical quantities.

## Noether’s Theorem Today

Today, it's nearly impossible to find a quantum field theory textbook that does not explore the intricate relationship between symmetry and conservation laws. A glance at recent publications in theoretical physics reveals a multitude of articles prominently featuring Noether’s name, underscoring the foundational impact of her theorem in the field.

Noether’s theorem serves as a crucial tool for physicists in two primary contexts. Initially, when working within a well-established theory, physicists analyze the mathematical formulations to identify intrinsic symmetries, which then help ascertain the conserved quantities. This process involves a detailed examination of the mathematical structure of the theory to uncover its symmetrical aspects and corresponding conservation laws.

Alternatively, in the absence of an existing theory, researchers may begin with the hypothesis that certain symmetries or conservation laws should be present in the theoretical framework they intend to develop. They then create mathematical models that embody these symmetries and analyze how these models reflect real-world phenomena. If the resulting theory accurately describes natural processes, it suggests that the proposed symmetries exist in nature. This methodological approach, leveraging Noether’s theorem, is commonplace among contemporary physicists, highlighting the theorem's pivotal role in guiding the development of new theoretical insights in the field.